SPRING SEMESTER 2009
TR 8:30-9:50
Social Science Center 107

DR. ERIC J. CARLSON
Office: SSC 117 Phone: 7692
E-mail: ecarlson@gustavus.edu
Drop-In Hours: T 2:30-4:00
and by appointment

Return to HIS-221 index page
The ideas and events known collectively as the Reformation have defined the nature of Christianity for nearly 500 years. In this course, we will examine these ideas and events, particularly through the perspective of the people who were central to them. The course places the Reformation in its historical context, beginning with a study of Christianity on the eve of the Reformation. It then examines the ways in which many reformers--Protestant and Catholic--viewed the Bible, salvation, the church, and the state. It looks at the struggle to implement the Reformation and at its legacy in the modern world. Since the course does these things, it satisfies the college's general education requirement for a course in Biblical and Theological Studies in the Christian tradition (THEOL).

My objectives are that you understand the following things:

  • the context in which the Reformation happened,
  • the main issues in the Reformation, as well as the differences between Protestants and Catholics and among the different Protestant traditions,
  • the effects and consequences of the Reformation, and
  • the relevance of the Reformation for Christianity in the 21st century.

In addition, you should develop an appreciation for the values of past societies, increase your understanding of the nature of historical inquiry and the work of historians of the Reformation, and begin to appreciate the difficulties of reconstructing the past. Your achievement of these objectives will be formally assessed through discussions and exams. You will be invited at the end of the semester to evaluate both the extent to which

the course was constructed in a way which advanced those objectives and the extent to which you believe that you have personally achieved them.

Studying the Reformation always helps me to think more clearly about what it is that I believe. It may have the same result for you. However, that is not a topic for the classroom. Our purpose in this class is to study and understand the past. The class is not a forum for individuals to promote a particular set of religious beliefs or to criticize the beliefs of others. While the Reformation--like other historical events--has left a legacy that is with us today (which we will examine at the end of the semester), our primary purpose is to consider and strive to understand the past as the past, which means speaking with a certain intellectual detachment even about issues that may be personally important to us today.


The Crucifixion -- A. Durer (late 15th c.)
Graded Requirements

I expect you to attend class. (My attendance policy is explained below.) But just showing up isn't enough! Informed participation in all class discussions is essential to the process of active learning. The reading on which discussions will be based is indicated in the calendar below. Your participation in class (its quality, not its frequency) will be worth up to 20 points of your final grade. Please note that asking informed questions is as valuable as other forms of participation and will be recognized in grading. There will be three exams, worth collectively up to 70 points. There will also be a short paper due at the end of the semester. It will be worth 10 points. Links to exam study guides and take-home exam questions appear in the semester calendar below; they (and the paper assignment) will also be linked to the HIS-221 index page.

Fair warning: Failure to take and pass all exams, or a pattern of failure to complete reading assignments, and/or engage in informed participation may result in an F for the course. If you have a problem, please see me before it becomes a crisis!

Attendance Policy

Everyone is allowed two absences--the equivalent of one week of class--without any negative consequences. I don't make a distinction between 'excused' and 'unexcused' absences, so don't feel that you need to explain your absences to me. However, I do appreciate the courtesy of advance warning (even ten minutes before class by phone or e-mail) so that I don't wait for you before beginning the day's activities. Between three and six absences may result in reduction of your final course grade, unless the absences are required by illness or personal/family emergency, or participation in a college-sponsored activity. In such cases, you must provide documentation and demonstrate that you have done the day's assignment. (The supervising faculty member is required by college policy to provide you with a letter for your instructors spelling out the dates, times and details of necessary absences for such activities.) More than six absences, regardless of the reason, mnay result in an F for the course. Make-up exams and extra time to submit at-home exams is possible in cases of illness, fam,ily emergency, or absence for co-curricular activities--but please speak to me in advance about that rather than assuming it.

Additional Policies
  1. Gustavus's academic honesty code, including the Honor Pledge, is enforced in this class. If violated, I will file a report with the Dean's office; the violator may fail the course.
  2. If you have a diagnosed learning disability or any health situation (physical or mental) that might have an impact on your ability to complete your assignments, it is your responsibility to let me know about it at the beginning of the semester. I will make every reasonable accommodation. (See Laurie Bickett in the Advising Center for documentation.)
  3. Cell phones should be turned off during class. If you are expecting an urgent call, set the phone to alert you silently, let me know that you may have to leave during class to take the call, and sit by the door for an inconspicuous departure.
  4. If you borrow course materials from me or the library, you are expected to return them unmarked and undamaged. You will not receive a grade for HIS-221 until all borrowed materials have been returned, or until damaged materials have been replaced.
  5. Late arrival is sometimes unavoidable, and I would ordinarily prefer that you come late than not at all. However, late arrival is distracting and should be avoided. If it becomes a pattern, there will be unpleasant consequences--a grade reduction or being locked out of the class. If you do come late, please enter as quietly as possible and sit by the door.

Books

The following are available in The Book Mark:
Alister McGrath, Reformation Thought (3rd ed.)
Denis R. Janz, A Reformation Reader (2nd ed.)
Richard Wunderli, Peasant Fires
Scott Hendrix, Recultivating the Vineyard
Barbara B. Diefendorf, The Saint Bartholomew's Day Massacre

Calendar
Some items are on e-reserve (Moodle). If a link appears below, the item is available on an open source (rather than e-reserve).
THEME 1: LATE MEDIEVAL CHRISTIANITY
Historical events are never entirely inevitable; all build upon the foundations of the society in which they occur. In order to understand the Reformation, we need to examine late medieval Christianity, especially in Germany. As we do so, consider these questions: What are the strengths and weaknesses of that church? What does knowing about the late medieval church contribute to under-standing the causes and attractions of the Reformation? Should the church have seen the Reformation coming or was it right to be surprised by it?
Feb. 10 Geographical Settings and Political Contexts
Feb. 12 Introduction to the Late Medieval Church Reader, docs. 2-3; Hendrix, 1-17
Feb. 17 Late Medieval Christianity in Germany, I
Peasant Fires, 1-71;
Reader, docs. 12-14
Feb. 19 Late Medieval Christianity in Germany, II
Peasant Fires, 72-150
Feb. 24 Medieval Ideas about God:Augustine, Realism, Nominalism
Reformation Thought, 66-78;
Reader, docs. 10-11
Feb. 26 Reform, Renewal and Dissent within the Late Medieval Church: Piety and the Christian Life
Reader, doc. 1; Hendrix, 17-35
G. Grote, Sermon; "Edifying Points of the Older Sisters"
March 3 Reform, Renewal and Dissent within the Late Medieval Church: Piety and the Christian Life
Reformation Thought, 39-65; Reader, docs. 8, 16;
Erasmus: excerpts from The Handbook of a Militant Christian(Moodle); "The Shipwreck" & "Cyclops"

Erasmus -- by Hans Holbein Ygr.
March 5 Reform, Renewal and Dissent within the Late Medieval Church: Institutional Reform
Colet's Convocation Sermon & Contarini's On the Office of Bishop
March 10 First Exam Click here for study guide

THEME 2: REFORMATION THOUGHT

In this unit, we will look at the main ideas of the major reformers (Luther, Zwingli and Calvin), as well as those of the radical group known as the Anabaptists. Be alert in particular to (1) the roots of the reformers' ideas in medieval theology and (2) agreements and disagreements among the reformers. How great a break with the past does the Reformation offer? Why were the Anabaptists considered such a threat by the mainstream reformers? Are the ideas of Luther, Zwingli and Calvin different enough that the label "Reformation" suggests an inaccurate commonality, or is there a common underlying agenda, as argued by Scott Hendrix?

Illustration (left):
title page of Martin Luther's treatise
On the Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520)

March 12 Who were the Reformers?
Reformation Thought, 86-99;
Reader, docs. 17-19; 47-8, 55; 68-9
March 17

Ideas about Salvation: Justification, Providence & Predestination

Reformation Thought, 101-25, 132-44;
Reader, docs. 22, 25, 77, 79, 83

March 19 Ideas about the Bible
Reformation Thought, 145-65;
Reader, docs. 26-7, 50, 78
Luther "Sermon on the Raising of Lazarus" (Moodle)
March 31 Ideas about Worship and the Sacraments
Reformation Thought, 169-94;
Reader, docs. 52-4, 85
Karlstadt, On the Removal of Images (Moodle)
April 2 Ideas about the Church
Reformation Thought, 197-218;
Reader, docs. 70-1, 84
April 7 Ideas about Government and Politics
Reformation Thought, 219-34;
Reader, doc. 86
April 9 A Common Agenda
Hendrix, 37-96

detail from The Raising of Lazarus by Guercino
April 14 Radical Reform: Anabaptism Reader, docs. 56, 58-9, 61-2, 65-7; Hans Hut, "On the Mystery of Baptism (Moodle)
Hendrix, 97-114

April 16 Catholic Reform: The Council of Trent
Reformation Thought, 125-31, 165-8, 195-6;
Reader, docs. 102, 105-8 plus Janz's intro on Council of Trent (p. 379)
The Second Exam (at-home) will be available on April 15. Click here for the exam.
The exam is due by 1:00 p.m. on Monday, April 20.

Cover page of pamphlet on the Peasant Revolt of 1525
THEME 3: THE REFORMATION IN PRACTICE
Ideas are one thing; practice is another. In this unit, we will examine a number of different responses to the Reformation. We will look at Protestant territories and the ways in which the ideas of the Reformers were selectively adopted by the laity and modified in the process of implementation and enforcement, and we will see what happened in the Roman church. In this unit, think about these questions: Was the Reformation of the laity the same as that of the Reformers? How and why did the Reformers themselves make changes in their original vision? Was the Catholic experience only a reaction against Protestantism or was it a parallel reformation? What effects did the Reformation have on European society? Was there more change or continuity with the past?
April 21 The Reformation According to the Laity
Miriam Usher Chrisman, "Lay Response to the Protestant Reformation in Germany, 1520-1528" (Moodle)
Lorna Jane Abray, "The Laity's Religion: Lutheranism in Sixteenth-Century Strasbourg" (Moodle)
April 23 Social Revolution
Reader, docs. 34-46
April 28 Official Implementation Strategies and their Effects: Protestant
Reader, docs. 28, 31-33
[Additional readings TBA]
April 30 Official Implementation Strategies and their Effects: Catholic
Hendrix, 212-47
Reader, docs. 109-17

Saint Ignatius
May 5 Effects on Gender and the Family
[Additional readings TBA]
May 7 Wars of Religion
Diefendorf, 1-35, 41-56, 65-74
May 12 Confessionalization; Success of Failure of the Reformation
Diefendorf, 82-111, 114-48;
Hendrix, 148-60

The Council of Trent
THEME 4: REFLECTIONS ON THE REFORMATION IN THE 21ST CENTURY
What is the relevance of the Reformation in our time? Are the issues that divided Christianity 500 years ago still relevant today? Have new issues emerged to exacerbate the divisions? This final unit briefly explores the divisions between Roman Catholics and Protestants, attempts to bridge the divides, and possibilities for a future reunification of Western Christianity.
May 14 Justification by Faith in the 21st Century
Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification & Incarnationis Mysterium
May 19 Christian Unity
Ut Unum Sint §1-14, 18-19, 28-30, 36-46, 64-72, 77-9, 86-99; "A Formula of Agreement"; Diefendorf, 154-8
Final Exam: In class, Monday, May 25 from 8:00-10:00; click here for study guide.